Skip to content
For SaleLuxury

$5,250,000

5,206 sqft$1,008/sqft67 days on market

25 S Duncan Drive

Montauk, NY 11954

View records
· 8% down, 7% APR, 30yr fixed

6

Beds

6

Baths

5,206

Square feet

2026

Built

Listing narrative

Description

This custom-built 5000+sf waterview residence offers a rare combination of scale, thoughtful design, and modern coastal living in Montauk. The home features 6 bedrooms and 5.5 bathrooms, including four ensuite bedrooms, delivering flexibility for full-time living or a high-end retreat. Interior living space spans three levels with a finished lower level (1482sf) ideal for additional recreation and gym use, a 1509sf main level, and a 1770sf second floor. A cathedral-ceiling great room anchors the main level, with oversized sliding doors that open directly to the lush yard, custom mahogany deck, sparkling 30x16 pool, and separate semi-recessed hot tub—creating a seamless indoor-outdoor flow. The kitchen is outfitted with a premium appliance package, complemented by European white oak engineered hardwood flooring throughout the main living areas. Climate control is handled by a high-efficiency VRF heat pump system providing year-round heating and cooling. Outdoor amenities include a 30' x 16' swimming pool, custom mahogany deck, and a separate semi-recessed hot tub, designed for both entertaining and everyday enjoyment. Additional features include an attached two-car garage (445sf) and a well-planned site layout. The primary bath is uniquely finished with a textured feature wall, freestanding soaking tub, matte black fixtures, a private water closet, and a stained wood vanity—delivering a clean, modern spa experience. A refined, move-in-ready offering in one of Montauk’s most desirable neighborhoods. 25 S Duncan Dr is the latest offering from BuildWell, led by Evan Pargonas, reflecting a commitment to holistic design and construction that prioritizes sustainability and net-zero goals.

Listing agent (MLS): Susan L. Fallon · Listing brokerage (MLS): Island Polo Realty Inc

Property Details

Key facts from the live listing feed are grouped here for quick review. Only fields confirmed by the active source are shown.

Price

$5,250,000

Beds

6 bd

Type

House

Home Size

5,206 sqft

Baths

6

Lot Size

0.51 acres

Year

2026

Status

For Sale

Days on Market

67

$ / Sqft

$1,008

· 8% down, 7% APR, 30yr fixed

Verified property data

Value, tax & last recorded sale

Public records available on the full property page

Estimated home value

Not available

Automated valuation estimate, not an appraisal. Value and range come from the connected property-data provider.

Public records are available on the full property page.

No record values are inferred or fabricated.

Full MLS property history

Confirmed unavailable from Atlas — listing-feed integration required for listing, relisting, price-change, status, pending, sold, withdrawn and expired events.

Loading map…

Courtesy of Island Polo Realty Inc